If one of your garage door panels gets damaged, you have two options: replace the damaged panel or replace the entire door. But which is the best choice?

When one or more of your garage door panels are dented or aged, it’s easy to think that the problem is limited to the panel’s outward appearance. However, this is usually not the case.

Learn when garage door panel replacement is the right choice, how much panel replacement costs, and why our experts don’t usually recommend installing only one garage door replacement panel.

Replacing damaged garage door panels can restore its functionality and the curb appeal of your home. Replacing a garage door panel may be the best option if:

• Damage is isolated: If the damage is limited to a single panel, and the surrounding panels are in good condition with no dents, cracks, or warping, replacing one panel may be the most cost-effective option.
• Damage is minor: Purely cosmetic damage that doesn’t affect the functionality of your garage door might mean you can opt for panel replacement.
• Panel type is available: You can easily find a replacement panel that matches your existing door’s style and size.

However, you may need to consider a full garage door replacement if:

• Garage doors are old: Age can lead to worn-out panels, weakened insulation, and potential security risks. Replacing the door in its entirety can be more cost-effective in the long run than investing in multiple repairs.
• Design not suitable for lifestyle: If your lifestyle needs have changed or you’ve done a home exterior remodel, and the door’s design no longer complements your home’s style, garage door replacement may offer a more suitable look.
• Extensive damage: If multiple panels are damaged or the door frame is compromised, replacing individual panels might not be feasible.
• Panel replacement isn’t possible: Sometimes, the damage is too severe for repair, or the panel material is no longer available. In such cases, a total garage door replacement becomes the best option.

The overall cost of garage door panel replacement depends on several factors, including the type of panel material, the complexity of the repair, and the labor rates in your area.

• Type of garage door: Sectional garage doors, the most common type, generally have a lower replacement cost per panel than less common types, such as roll-up or tilt-up doors. This is because they’re more readily available and standardized unlike less common door panels.
• Materials: Garage door panels come in various types of material such as steel, wood, aluminum, and composite, each come with a different price range too! Expect to pay between $150 to $1,000 for materials, depending on where you live. Steel and aluminum panels are generally cheaper while wood and composite tend to be more expensive.
• Labor: Labor costs will also vary depending on the experience of your service professional, your location, and the hours of labor required to replace the panel. Removing and installing a single panel on a sectional door is typically a quicker process compared to more extensive repairs that involve multiple panels or less common door styles. Labor costs can range from $200 to $500 or more depending on the factors mentioned above.

Garage door panel replacement is labor-intensive and dangerous because it involves working with heavy components and tension springs, which can cause serious injury if not handled properly. For safety reasons, leave this task to a qualified garage door professional.

Here’s an overview of the process:

1. Source the correct replacement panel: A professional will ensure they have the exact size and style of panel to match your existing door.
2. Prepare the door for replacement: A professional will secure the door and adjust the spring tension if necessary.
3. Remove the old door one panel at a time: A professional will safely remove the damaged panel(s) using the appropriate tools and techniques.
4. Remove the hardware from the old panel: A professional will meticulously remove any reusable hardware, such as rollers or hinges, from the old panel.
5. Apply hardware to the new panel: A professional will carefully transfer the hardware to the new panel, ensuring a proper fit and functionality.
6. Install the new panel: A professional will install and secure the new panel(s) according to the manufacturer’s specifications.
7. Test the garage door: The professional will thoroughly test the door’s functionality, ensuring smooth operation and proper sensor alignment. A pro will also make any necessary final adjustments to ensure optimal performance.

In cases of minor damage, you may be able to replace just one panel on a garage door. However, the damage to your garage door often equates to more than an eyesore. There could be internal damage you’re not aware of that could impact functionality and interfere with the performance of your garage door.

While replacing one garage door panel may seem easier or more cost-effective than replacing your entire garage door, you could be risking the following:

• Functionality: By only replacing a part of your door’s exterior, you may be covering up the damage rather than fixing the garage door. For this reason, we recommend having a trained service professional examine your door.
• Aesthetics: Even if there is no internal damage to your door, a new panel could affect your door’s appearance, as it may look out of place next to the other aged panels.
• Security: When your garage door’s functionality is affected, so is your home’s security. All damage to your door should be examined by a trained professional.

We recommend scheduling an appointment with a Precision Garage Door Service™ professional for an on-site visit to perform a 25-point safety inspection. Consulting with an experienced expert will save you a lot of worry and stress.

If your garage door is damaged and you’re considering garage door panel replacement, contact the professionals at your local Precision Garage Door Service. Our teams of skilled service professionals will schedule an on-site visit to examine your door and provide repair options that best meet your needs. To get started, find a Precision Garage Door Service location near you.

This article is intended for general informational purposes only and may not be applicable to every situation. You are responsible for determining the proper course of action for your property. Services should be performed by licensed and experienced professionals. Precision Garage Door Service is not responsible for any damages that occur as a result of this blog content or your actions. For the most accurate guidance, contact a Precision Garage Door Service professional for a comprehensive on-site assessment.